Tuesday, November 18, 2008

Abuse and Violence against women and children in society

Abuse and Violence against women and children in societyAbuse cases and killings by partners is on the increase. It is common for the so called lovers to kill each other in the name of love. This is especially happening among the young lovers or young couples. There is no empirical evidence so far to show the causes and the magnitude of the problem. What we know is that this is another cause of death third to AIDS and the road carnage in Botswana.

Violence against women and children can not be justified or acceptable in society.
It is indeed a crime. Violence:
• is life threatening.
• has no place in the family or in the community.
• is learned behavior. It can, therefore, be changed.
• is a choice.
• is a power issue.
• is never justified. No behavior of any woman justifies or provokes violence.
• is never the responsibility of the woman being abused. Responsibility for violence rests with the batterer.
• Does not stem from "loss of control". Control is what the batterer wants.
• Occurs in all classes, races, and cultural groups. The issue of violence is complex. We need to understand the social, personal, economic, political, cultural, and religious dimensions of violence in a multicultural context.

In the recent past in South Africa, Zimbabwean immigrant women and children faced specific problems, such as:
• xenophobia
• immigration policy/laws
• language barriers
• service access/lack of availability
• lack of experience with social services
• distrust of the judicial system
• isolation
• low economic status.

The community has the right and the responsibility to get involved. The more that is known about violence, the more effective the community can be in intervening and preventing violence against women and children. This could bring violence to an end...

Monday, November 17, 2008

Child Protection Perspective

Child protection is not a new concept..

Some attempts to protect and uphold the rights of the children can be traced to the 1924 Geneva Declaration on the Rights of the Child and the 1959 Declaration on the Rights of the Child. Other international treaties on child protection that have taken centre stage include the 1989 United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) and the 1996 Hague Convention on the protection of the child.

Most countries have shown their commitment to uphold the children’s rights by ratifying the Convention on the Rights of the Child except Somalia and the United States of America.

It is gratifying that almost all the countries have ratified the UNCRC and have pledged to make laws and repeal existing laws to make them consistent with the provisions of the Convention. However there is caution that, " the Convention on the Rights of the Child (the Convention) notwithstanding its near universal acceptance, must in many respects be viewed as a promising starting point on the long and winding road to the global improvement of the status of children" (Rwezaura, 1989:p). He argues that the world community is quite diverse socially, economically and culturally, and therefore cannot understand or interpret the Convention on the Rights of Child the same way.

There will always be culturally determined differences in the understanding of what sexual exploitation or abuse or what kind of work is risky to the child or what conduct, customs and practices are not in best interests of the child (An-Naim, 1992).

The methods and processes to protect and uphold the rights of children may vary quite considerably from one culture to another and from region to region. However, the underlying values and philosophy constituting the foundation of human dignity and integrity are largely cross-cultural and universal and hence the ability of the international community to reach normative consensus on the rights of the child as stipulated in the Convention (Ncube, 1998).

References
An-Naim. A, ‘and Goldbasch, 1992. Human Rights in Cross Cultural Perspectives, University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia. Ncube, W. 1998. (ed), Law, Culture, Tradition and Children's Rights in Eastern and Southern Africa. Brookfield, USA: Ashgate.Rwezaura, B. " Changing community Obligations to the Elderly in Contemporary Africa", Journal of Social Development in Africa 4, 1989.

Child Abuse Laws in Botswana

In Botswana there are several laws that are meant to address child abuse and neglect.

Here are some of the child abuse laws that protect children…

The Children’s Act and Child Abuse
The Children’s Act Section 11 finds any parent or guardian of a child or any person having custody of a child who neglects, mistreats or exploits a child guilty of an offence. Neglect may include the unreasonable failure to provide for adequate food, clothing, housing, health and care of the child and exposing a child to conditions or circumstances likely to cause him/her physical, mental or psychological distress or damage.

The Children’s Act also provides that any parent or guardian having custody of a child is guilty of an offence if s/he causes or conduces to the seduction, abduction or prostitution of the child.
Although the sale and trafficking of children is virtually unknown in the country, both the Penal Code and the Children’s Act make the abduction of children criminal offences.

Penal Code
The Penal Code covers forms of abuse against children, namely, abduction of females for immoral purposes, abduction of persons below 16 years, indecent assault of young children, defilement of persons below 16 years of age, unlawful carnal knowledge of children
The Penal Code has provisions which deal with sexual abuse and exploitation. Section 141 holds that any person who has unlawful carnal knowledge of another person or who causes the penetration of a sexual organ or instrument into the person of another without consent is guilty of rape.

The Employment ActThe Employment Act protects children against exploitation and hazardous employment. The Act defines a child as a person under the age of 15 years and a young person as a person who has attained the age of 15 years but is under the age of 18 years. The law permits employment of children 13 to 15 years of age in light work that is unlikely to be harmful to their health or development and that will not prejudice their benefiting from school or vocational programmes. No child shall be permitted to work more than 6 hours a day or 30 hours a week.

Birth Registration Act
The CRC states that every child has the right to a name and a nationality and the right to protection from being deprived of his or her identity. Therefore birth registration is a fundamental means of securing these rights for children.

Botswana has a Births and Deaths Registration Act which makes birth registration compulsory. There is a Department of Civil and National Registration in the Ministry of Labour and Home Affairs which is responsible for the registration of civil registration and national identity cards in the country.

So far, the department has 32 registration offices countrywide, 30 of which are networked. In order to reach remote areas, the department has mobile offices which register civil events and issue national identity cards and birth certificates. Any person who has attained age 16 years must have a national identity card.

A levy of BWP5.00 (US$1.00) to a maximum of BWP500.00 (US$100.00) is charged for late registration. At the moment, there are no waivers for any communities, including children under the age of 18 years. A maximum of BWP500.00 (US$100.00) or six months imprisonment or both fine and charge is administered for late registration. AT the moment, there are no waivers for any communities, including children under the age of 18 years.

Removal of an abused child to a place of safety

There’s an old adage that says ignorance of the law is no excuse...


Many people remain ignorant of the law despite all efforts to ensure that laws are published in the Government gazette for them to read them. Who is to blame for the society’s ignorance of the law? Here’s how to remove a child to a place of safety in Botswana under the Children in need of care Regulations…


Section 15 (1) of the Children’s Act of 1981 provides that where any person observing a child has reasonable cause to believe that the child is in need of care he shall immediately make a report thereof to the social welfare or a police officer in the district in which the child resides.


A social welfare officer or a police officer to whom a report has been made under the above section may remove or cause to be removed to a place of safety the child in question and shall as soon as thereafter as may be , subject to the provisions of section 17 (5), bring the child or cause him or her to be brought before the children’s court of the district in which the child is resident..


The child has to be brought before the court within 5 days of the removal.Where there is no immediate need for the removal of the child to a place of safety, the court may order that the parent or guardian of the child to bring the child before the court on a specified date.
The police officer who carries out the removal of the child to a place of safety must have an order in writing from the children’s court.


Power of a parent or guardian to bring a child before the Court Under Regulation 4 a parent or guardian who brings a child before the Court on the ground that he or she is unable to control the child, and that the child be dealt with the child as a child in need of care has to sign a consent form.


The best interests of the childThe best interests of the child shall be the paramount consideration in determining any question with respect to the removal of the child to an institution or a foster home.


When determining the best interests of the child, the following key factors are taken into consideration:

• The ascertainable wishes and feelings of the child in the light of the child’s age and understanding;

• The physical, emotional and educational needs of the child;

• The likely effect on the child of any change in his or her environment;

• the age, sex, background and any other relevant characteristics of the child.

• any harm already suffered or that is likely to be suffered by the child, if the child is not removed from his or her home.


Home environment similar to that of natural parentsWhen making an order for the placement of a child with a foster parent, if it is in the best interest of the child, the child shall be placed in a home environment similar to that of his or her natural parents. This is to curb further trauma and stress related with the environment.


Delay is likely to be prejudicial.
In the proceedings relating to the removal of a child to an institution or foster home the court must apply the general principle that any delay in determining the question is likely to be prejudicial to the welfare of the child.

Sunday, November 16, 2008

8 Key Causes of Child abuse

Here are the 8 key causes of child abuse in Botswana:

1. HIV/AIDS Scourge
The HIV/AIDS epidemic has had serious dire consequences for children, most notably in fuelling the orphan crisis. Using the international definition which states that an orphan is a “child below the age of 18 who has lost one or both parents” the prevalence of orphans among children below 18 years in Botswana is 17.2% (137,805 children) (National Situation Analysis 2007). The Botswana definition states that an orphan is a ‘child below 18 years who has lost one (single) or both parents (married couples), biological or adoptive, the prevalence of orphans among children below 18 years stands at 6.5% (51,806 children by end of 2007).

Orphans are potentially extremely vulnerable to child abuse and exploitation, to withdrawal from education, to child labour, to emotional distress and trauma. It is recognised that orphans and vulnerable children have complex psychosocial needs which cannot be met by food baskets alone. Elderly female care givers are under serious stress due to role reversal. The movement of children between relatives for access to their benefits, for domestic and agricultural labour is a cause of concern.

The impact of the scourge is also experienced by children who are not necessarily orphaned. The National Situation Analysis 2007 found a prevalence rate of 4.4%, for children vulnerable because they lived in a household where there was a person who had been critically ill for at least 3 months.

2. Poverty
Children can become vulnerable due to poverty and especially absolute poverty. In the National Situation Analysis 30.6% of the children were found to be vulnerable because they lived in a household where there is no one gainfully employed. The effects of poverty are being compounded by the impacts of environmental factors including drought, flooding and climate change which can lead to loss of livelihoods and homes and internal displacement.

3. Dysfunctional families
Some children struggle to grow up in families prone to internal conflicts, alcoholism, violence, abuse and poor parenting skills. These children are unlikely to enjoy their fundamental rights and are even driven onto the streets to support themselves. Children with unmet emotional needs are also particularly vulnerable to sexual exploitation.

4. Discrimination and marginalisation of minority groups
Some children from minority groups, especially San children can be found living in appalling conditions in squatter encampments on the outskirts of some of the country’s towns and large villages. These children’s basic rights to education, health care and shelter are compromised. They are extremely vulnerable to abuse.

5. Abandonment, child labour and Child headed households
A child may be vulnerable due to a wide range of circumstances such as abandonment, child labour, heading a household, living in a household headed by a child, disability, internal displacement, illegal immigration, separation from parents, imprisonment of parents especially mothers, residence in squatter settlements, residence on remote farms and unmet psychosocial needs even in financially secure families.

6. Gender Issues
Boys and girls may be vulnerable, but in gender specific ways. Girls are more likely to be sexually abused, engaged in transactional and intergenerational sex, and used in domestic labour. Boys may be withdrawn from school for agricultural labour or to work on the streets. Both boys and girls are heading households and caring for their younger siblings.

7. The health status of children
35.5% of Botswana’s population is under the age of 15 years. In terms of health status, the country has relatively high infant mortality and under-five mortality rates [87 & 120 per 1,000 live births respectively ] and it is estimated that around 14,000 children aged 0-14 years are living with HIV. The good news is that in 2005, 84% of these children who were in need received ART, the highest percentage in sub-Saharan Africa .

8. Access and retention of children in education
While there is high enrolment rate of children into primary education [almost 95%], not all these children complete their basic education, and drop out rates are high in remoter rural areas.
Pre school provision remains very patchy and is largely provided by civil society organisations with limited and often insecure access to resources. Although 2009 will see the beginning of the roll out of formal pre-school education for four year olds, this will still leave a significant unmet need.

Afrigator

Birth Registration: A Child’s important step towards accessing essential services

Birth Registration is a child’s important step towards accessing essential services..

The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child provides that a child has a right to a name and a nationality. The Convention provides for the registration of a child immediate after birth. It is unfortunate that in 2006, births around 15 million children went unregistered.

Birth registration is one of the fundamental rights of children and is a prerequisite to fulfilling other human rights and access to essential services. This includes access to education, health care, and protection from child labor, child marriage, underage military service, child trafficking, and harassment by police.

Civil registration is of utmost importance for both states and individuals affected by HIV and AIDS. In 2006, 36 % of the 51 million children who born have not had their birth registration were found in Sub-Saharan Africa. Sub-Saharan Africa also has the highest HIV prevalence rate in the world and the number of children orphaned by AIDS in this region is projected to keep increasing.

A child’s birth certificate may ensure success to key HIV prevention, treatment, care and support services, such as health care, education and other services. A parent’s death certificate is of equal critical importance for the child’s right to inheritance and properly to be protected. A child with a birth certificate “has so many chances… It will be very good for that child” (focus group discussion with HIV positive parents, Mukujju health Centre, Uganda, August 2008).
The Committee of United nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (2008) General Comment No. 3: HIV/AIDS and the rights of the child said:
“The committee wishes to emphasize the critical implications of proof of identity for children affected by HIV/AIDS as it relates to securing recognition as a person before the law, safeguarding the protection of rights, in particular to inheritance, education, health and other social services… In this respect birth registration is critical to ensuring the rights of the child and is also necessary to minimize the impact of HIV/AIDS on the lives of affected children”.

A strong civil registration system also helps policy and decision-makers meet the challenges of HIV/AIDS by planning the appropriate scale of budget allocations and distribution of prevention, treatment, care and support services. Such systems keep track of AIDS IN terms of the total number of AIDS-related deaths, the survival rate of those on ART and the number of children affected and orphaned by the pandemic.

The data compiled by birth and death registration further provides the foundation for achieving the Millennium Development Goals (MDG), such as MDG 4, reducing child mortality, and MDG 6, combating HIV/AIDS.

The Best Interest of the Child: Is it always given paramount consideration?

The best interest of the child should be given paramount consideration at all times to ensure protection of children from all forms of abuse and neglect. Our concern is whether the best interest is always given paramount consideration by key service providers.

The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child provides that the best interests of the child will always be of paramount consideration when dealing matters affecting the child’s well-being
Factors that come to mind that can be taken into account in determining the best interests of the child include:
• the need to protect the child from harm;
• the capacity of the child’s parents or other person to care for and protect the child;
• the child’s spiritual, physical, emotional and educational needs;
• the child’s age, maturity, sex, background, and language;
• the child’s cultural, ethnic or religious identity;
• the likely effect on the child of any change in the child’s circumstances;
• the importance of stability and continuity in the child’s living arrangements and the likely effect on the child of any change in, or disruption of, those arrangements; and
• any wishes or views expressed by the child, having regard to the child’s age, maturity and level of understanding in determining the weight to be given to those wishes or views; or
• any other factor which will ensure the general well – being of the child.
• No discrimination against any child on the basis of sex, family, color, race, ethnicity, place of origin, language, religion, economic status, parents, physical or mental status, or any other status;
• Children including those who are most vulnerable to be exposed to the same challenges, activities and opportunities that promote their health and development as all other children.
• every child shall be cared for and protected from harm;
• the parents, family and community of a child have the primary responsibility of safeguarding and promoting the child’s well – being;
• every child shall have stable, secure and safe relationships and living arrangements;
• every child shall have the most appropriate form of care for his or her development .

Experience has shown that people who want custody of children are not always honest in dealing with the best interest of the child. Even social workers involved in such matters at times find themselves being swayed by the best interests of adults as opposed to those of children. For instance those who tell the truth in ambiguous areas like determination of custody and child abuse, are often hesitant in speech, while those who lie come across as very sure of what they are saying, and hence make a better impression upon many magistrate courts.

On many occasions, some dishonest persons who have their own best interests at heart in visitation rights and custody battles care only about what they want and not about what is in the best interest of the child. It is important for the social workers to guard against being swayed by these kind of people to the detriment of the very children that they want to protect.

Civil Registration and International commitments

Civil Registration is based on International commitments that have been made to safeguard the rights and well-being of children worldwide.

Welcome on borad and learn more about civil registration..

Strengthening civil registration systems is a government responsibility: birth registration is a child’s human right.

Most National plans of action (NPA) for orphans and vulnerable children do not explicitly acknowledge that birth registration is a human right, however. No NP has recognized the value of death registration in protecting children from property and inheritance loss, which is a human rights and livelihoods issue.

International Policy Commitments on Civil Registration

• Article 7 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child gives every child the right to be registered at birth by the state within whose jurisdiction the child is born.
• The 2002 World Fit for Children reaffirms governments’ commitment to ensure the birth registration for all children.

• The 2004 Global Framework for the protection, care and support of Orphans and Vulnerable Children Living in a World with HIV and AIDS calls for access for orphans and vulnerable children to essential services, including birth Registration, to be ensured.

• The 2006 Global Partners Forum identified civil registration to be one of the strategic areas of importance to building a comprehensive response for children affected by HIV/AIDS.
Poverty, exacerbated by HIV and AIDS, hinders the demand by parents to register their children, as meagre finances are rather spent on education and health requirements, including ART, clothing, nutrition, and shelter.

More often civil registration systems are centralized, impeding the access of those that have to travel long distances. Indirect costs of obtaining a birth or death certificate usually outweigh the direct costs. However, urbanization does not significantly impact on increased registration rates.

Tentative recommendations for scaling up strong civil registration systems

1. A decentralized community-based approach to registering vital data and disturbing certificates can reduce or nullify indirect costs. At the same time, the community collectors sensitize and raise the awareness of individual households and community members to the importance of birth or death registration. Registering data at the district or provincial level allows local government to identify and monitor orphaned and vulnerable children, increasing the efficiency of the delivery of services to these people.

2. Specific national legislations and policies pertaining to civil registration need to be developed and implemented, recognizing the importance of such systems on the state’ s responsibility to monitor its citizens and provide them with comprehensive basic services, including appropriate HIV-related prevention, treatment, support and care programmes for adults and children protection should be highlighted, and especially for orphans access to property and inheritance rights.

3. Birth and death registration awareness should be incorporated and integrated into HIV and AIDS programming , such as adult’s and children’s voluntary counseling and testing , PMTCT and ante and post-natal programmes, youth and children’s life skills courses ,HIV and AIDS support groups, and children’s and youth’s knowledge and practice in relation to health, sexuality and HIV.

Saturday, November 15, 2008

Child abuse and the Media

How child friendly is the media fraternity?

This is a million dollar question that we need to answer especially in respect of what obtains on the ground...

The media in most cases has not been child friendly especially in reporting cases of child abuse. There has been negative reporting and gross violation of children's rights in the process of reporting.

The media has an important role to play in shaping public knowledge, attitudes and creating awareness. The media should assist government in child abuse preventive education and community building. As such, the media should be used to provide well balanced and non emotive information on:

• Child abuse and neglect.
• Sexual exploitation.
• Life skills
• Parenting skills
• The needs and positive development of children

Instead of reporting negatively about abused children the media should play a watchdog role or function to ensure constructive and well balanced reporting on children’s issues. The media should avoid negative education at all costs such as publicizing materials that are damaging to children and their families. Moreover the media should not foster the impression that violence and indiscriminate sexual activity are normal.

The media should continuously provide vital information on the available services for abused and children to create awareness among community members.

Children should also have an opportunity to play a role in the media because children learn better and grasp information more quickly from each other. Children have the right to speak out on matters that affect them. Their opinions must be heard and respected.

The media should facilitate a process where children can openly speak about matters that are important to them and to the people around them. As such, grownups should ask them what they think and listen to what they have to say instead of shutting them up.

It is important for children to be given the opportunity to be heard where their future is discussed. This is to ensure that they meaningfully participate in matters that affect their rights and well-being.

The media should denounce negative cultural and religious practices that are detrimental to the well-being of children such as female genital mutilation and forced marriages.

On the basis of the foregoing statements, no person shall publish the name and address of any child brought before a children’s court or the name or address of any school which that child is or has been attending, or any photograph of that child, or any matter likely to lead to the identification of that child.

Any person who contravenes any provision of this section shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable to conviction thereof.

How To Identify Signs of Child Sexual Abuse

Can members of the community identify signs of child sexual abuse?
Sexual exploitation and child sexual abuse are increasing rapidly in Botswana despite the existing legal mechanisms forbidding these practices and the stiff penalties that have been introduced to deter the culprits.

With the advent of HIV/AIDS pandemic children especially girls are more vulnerable to sexual abuse for several reasons which include material inducement offered to them by older men in exchange for sex. Some children succumb to sexual exploitation because of poverty and insecurity due to unreliable income in the household.

Incest as a form of child sexual abuse is more common than it has been documented mainly due to under-reporting of the offence. There are several explanations for the under- reporting which are among others, the secrecy surrounding the problem.

The perpetrators of child sexual abuse are usually close relatives of the victims and consequently there is a stigma associated with the commissioning of the offence, which normally makes the victims to shy away from the problem and choose to remain silent. It is been observed that associated with the stigma is the fear that reporting the matter might bring tensions and misunderstandings among relatives.

Case study 1: Incest

Mpho is a 15-year-old girl who is cared for by her uncle, who is a traditional doctor. She has five siblings: a twin brother who suffers from epilepsy (which the uncle is treating), a 13 year old sister, Marea, twin brothers who are ten years old and a small sister who is 6 years old. Her uncle has turned her into a surrogate wife (his own wife is not around) and Mpho has an ongoing sexual relationship with him. She lives with him in a newly built brick house while the other children live in a dilapidated reed hut across the compound. Mpho is responsible for seeing that her younger siblings are fed and clothed and she exerts control over them. She keeps Marea dressed in ragged, too-small childish dress. When they received a donation of some (girl's) clothes she gave one or two items to each of the children except Marea who got nothing and Mpho kept most for herself.

This case study is a tip of the ice berg... you know better...

The number of cases of child sexual abuse reported to the police is high and increasing at an alarming rate. Many cases of this nature go unreported because children as victims are powerless. This is so because the perpetrators are often breadwinners in the household and reporting them undermines the family income.

In most cases the abuse takes place in the family setting and therefore such cases are rarely reported due to coercion by the perpetrator, shame and fear on the part of the child.
The Children’s Act Section 11 finds any parent or guardian of a child or any person having custody of a child who neglects, mistreats or exploits a child guilty of an offence.

Neglect include the unreasonable failure to provide for adequate food, clothing, housing, health and care of the child and exposing a child to conditions or circumstances likely to cause him/her physical, mental or psychological distress or damage.

The Children’s Act also provides that any parent or guardian having custody of a child is guilty of an offence if s/he causes or conduces to the seduction, abduction or prostitution of the child.
Section 12 (1) of the Children's Act provides that any parent or guardian having the custody of a child who causes or conduces to the seduction, abduction or prostitution of the child or the commissioning by the child of an immoral act shall be guilty of an offence.

In criminal cases, where the child is a victim of child sexual abuse, the proceedings are held in camera to protect the identity of the child. Only authorised officials and the parents of the child are allowed inside the courtroom. Members of the press are also not allowed to report on the matter or take pictures of the victim. The proceedings can not be published disclosing the identity of the child as stipulated in Section 172 of the Criminal Procedure and Evidence Act.

Section 171 of the Botswana Penal Code provides that no cases of incest are prosecuted without the written consent from the Attorney General's Chambers. It is believed that cases of incest are controversial and normally bring conflicts between members of the same family. So it has been found necessary to establish first whether there is sufficient evidence to prosecute.